Viral Video Sparks Fresh Debate Around Dhurandhar
A new debate has emerged around the portrayal of realism in Dhurandhar and its sequel Dhurandhar: The Revenge, after a viral video featuring a Pakistani viewer sharing his opinions gained traction online.
The films, directed by Aditya Dhar and starring Ranveer Singh and Sara Arjun, explore the story of an Indian spy operating within a crime network in Lyari.
Pakistani Viewer Calls Film ‘Overrated’
In the viral clip shared by an Indian influencer, a Pakistani man described the film as “a little overrated,” while questioning certain narrative elements.
He particularly pointed out a dialogue suggesting that controlling Lyari could influence larger political power, stating that such a claim felt unrealistic from his perspective as someone familiar with the region.
Questions Over Cultural Accuracy
The discussion also touched on how Lyari and Karachi are depicted in the film.
While acknowledging that gang-related issues exist, the viewer suggested that the scale and impact portrayed in the film were exaggerated for cinematic effect.
He also raised concerns about visual details, including language used on signboards and cultural representation in certain scenes.
Sara Arjun’s Character Draws Attention
One of the most talked-about aspects of the video was the portrayal of Yalina Jamali, played by Sara Arjun.
The viewer questioned the styling and mobility of the character in the film’s setting, suggesting it did not align with his understanding of local realities.
Creative Liberty vs Realism
The video also highlighted broader questions about creative liberty in cinema.
From costumes and music choices to dramatic plot points—including the central relationship and elopement storyline—several elements were described as heightened for narrative impact rather than strict realism.
Mixed Reactions Online
The video has sparked varied responses across social media:
- Some viewers agreed with the critique, calling for more authentic storytelling
- Others defended the film, pointing out that mainstream cinema often prioritises drama and scale over realism
Despite the debate, many acknowledged the film’s strengths, including its cinematography and music.
Final Take
The discussion around Dhurandhar underscores a recurring tension in cinema—balancing authenticity with storytelling.
While critiques about realism continue to surface, the film’s popularity suggests that audiences are equally drawn to its larger-than-life narrative.
