Is ‘The Testaments’ Worth Watching? Critics Weigh In on Hulu’s ‘Handmaid’s Tale’ Sequel

Hulu’s The Testaments has quickly become one of the most talked-about streaming releases of 2026, expanding the universe of The Handmaid’s Tale with a new generation-driven dystopian story. Following strong early viewership, the series has already been renewed for a second season.

But the key question remains: does it succeed as a standalone drama, and is it worth watching for both new viewers and fans of the original series?

A New Chapter in Gilead

Based on Margaret Atwood’s 2019 novel, The Testaments is set approximately four years after the events of The Handmaid’s Tale. The story returns to the authoritarian regime of Gilead, a theocratic society formed after the collapse of the United States, where women are controlled through rigid social roles.

Unlike its predecessor, which focused on Elisabeth Moss’s character June Osborne, the sequel shifts attention to a younger generation raised entirely within Gilead’s system.

At the center of the story are two teenage girls, Agnes and Daisy, who meet at an elite institution designed to train future wives. Agnes is revealed to be connected to June’s past, while Daisy’s arrival sets off a chain of events that challenges both characters’ understanding of identity, loyalty, and survival.

Returning Characters and New Perspectives

One of the key returning figures is Aunt Lydia, once one of Gilead’s most feared enforcers. Played again by Ann Dowd, the character continues to evolve as the series explores her shifting relationship with the regime she helped build.

Critics have noted that Lydia’s storyline provides one of the most compelling emotional threads, adding continuity between the original series and the new narrative.

Do You Need to Watch ‘The Handmaid’s Tale’ First?

According to showrunner Bruce Miller, prior knowledge of The Handmaid’s Tale is not required to follow The Testaments. The series is designed to function as a standalone story, with its own entry point and character focus.

However, viewers familiar with the original series may gain deeper context, especially regarding Gilead’s structure and Aunt Lydia’s backstory.

Critical Reception: A Divided Response

Early reviews for The Testaments have been generally positive, though not without criticism.

Some reviewers praised the series for its fresh perspective on Gilead, highlighting its focus on adolescence, identity, and resistance within oppressive systems. Others described it as a strong continuation that expands the emotional and political scope of the franchise.

Chase Infiniti’s performance as Agnes has also drawn early attention, with some critics suggesting she could become a breakout awards contender.

However, not all feedback has been favorable. Some critics argue that the series occasionally leans too heavily on familiar themes from The Handmaid’s Tale, limiting its sense of originality. Others pointed to uneven pacing and moments where the plot feels overly familiar to the original series.

Despite these concerns, the performances and world-building have been widely recognized as strengths.

Should You Watch It?

For fans of dystopian drama, The Testaments offers a continuation of one of television’s most influential universes, while also attempting to carve out its own identity through younger characters and a different narrative focus.

While opinions remain mixed, the series is widely seen as engaging, emotionally driven, and strong enough to justify its expansion of the franchise.